Imogen Macdonald

Winter Reading Challenge

I'm doing Winter Reading Challenge for Dementia UK

This winter, I'm reading and raising funds to help ensure no family faces dementia alone. I'm taking on the challenge for Dementia UK, the specialist dementia nursing charity, and would be grateful for your support.

Your donation, big or small, makes a difference. £33 could fund a new dementia specialist Admiral Nurse to spend an hour helping a family in the community, offering practical solutions and emotional support to cope with their loved one’s distressed behaviour.

Thank you!

My Achievements

Shared Page

Updated Profile Pic

Added a Blog Post

You've Self Donated!

Received 5 Donations

Reached Fundraising Goal

Increased Target Over £250

My Updates

Review #7 - Rebecca

Sunday 15th Nov
Rebecca - Daphne du Maurier

📚 Genre: Gothic fiction

📚 Synopsis: The heroine of the story starts out serving as a companion to a busybody of an older American lady, Mrs Van Hopper. On a trip to Monte Carlo, she meets Maxim de Winter, a charming widower who she quickly falls in love with, and they are soon married.

On their return to Manderley, his grand family estate, our heroine tries to find her feet in a world of grandeur and social etiquette that is unfamiliar to her. But with reminders of the late Mrs de Winter lurking in every corner of Manderley and its grounds, our heroine struggles to settle into her new home and to compete with the memory of the seemingly perfect Rebecca...

📚 My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ and a 1/2

Now this is a book that my high school English teacher told me to read because she thought I'd enjoy it. I bought it back in 2011 and it has sat on my bookshelf ever since. So Ms. Pirie, if you ever happen to see this, I finally read it and loved it! 🤣

This one has probably taken me the longest to read of all the books I've read as part of the challenge so far. It was quite a slow burn to begin with and I always find it a bit of a gear shift picking up a classic because the language is so very different. I wasn't getting through it very quickly at first, but around three quarters of the way through a truth bomb gets dropped and I remember thinking, 'Right, NOW it's getting interesting!'

The heroine of the story is an interesting character. She starts off very unsure of herself, clearly anxious and insecure, and this is only exaggerated when she arrives at Manderley and finds herself living in the shadow of Rebecca. She constantly compares herself to the picture of Rebecca she's built up in her mind from snippets and stories shared by those who knew the late Mrs de Winter. Interestingly, the reader never actually learns the main character's name either. She's only ever referred to as Mrs de Winter, which I think adds to the sense that she's not as important to the other characters as Rebecca was, and that she's struggling with the notion of how she could ever measure up to Rebecca.

My favourite thing about this book, though, was the eerie, secretive atmosphere that Daphne du Maurier manages to create. From the moment the main character and Maxim arrive at Manderley, there's this constant sense of unease and foreboding, as though something sinister is always just around the corner.

The descriptions of the surroundings are so detailed and beautifully crafted, and they evoke such a strong sense of place that Manderley almost becomes a character in itself because of what it represents. Mrs Danvers was also one of the more interesting characters, although very creepy!

In the beginning, you could be forgiven for thinking this is a romance, but you quickly start to realise that all isn't quite what it seems. The heroine's anxieties are so clearly communicated through the internal dialogue she conjures up about what other people might think of her, which makes it easy for the reader to understand just how out of her depth she feels, and also desperate for validation from her husband.

I can't say too much more without giving away spoilers, but if you like a book that's suspenseful, has a wonderfully eerie atmosphere and transports you to another place entirely, this is the one!

✨️📚 Book 7 📚✨️

Sunday 15th Nov
Rebecca - Daphne du Maurier

Update from Dementia UK

Saturday 31st Oct
Lovely update on the Winter Reading Challenge Facebook group to say that collectively, readers have already raised over £17,000! 👏🙏✨️

Review #6 - Mad Mabel

Friday 30th Oct
Mad Mabel - Sally Hepworth

📚 Genre: Mystery/Contemporary Fiction

📚 Synopsis: Mabel Waller has a history of unfortunate events happening around her, including a string of deaths of people connected to her in one way or another. Having been the youngest Australian ever to be convicted of murder, a playground nickname of "Mad Mabel" went on to become her infamous moniker across the world.

The story moves between Mabel's troubled younger years, where as a young girl she struggled to make friends, and the events of the present day. Now a curmudgeonly 81-year-old and going by the name Elsie Fitzpatrick, she lives a quiet, uneventful life (or at least tries to) in a suburb of Melbourne. That is, until an elderly neighbour is suddenly found dead.

As murmurs and suspicions begin to circulate and her neighbours start to learn of her real identity, Elsie finds herself facing the ghosts of her past. Only this time, she's given the chance to tell her side of the story and set the record straight on what really happened all those years ago.

📚 My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I think I can safely say I'm firmly in the fan club of fiction with stubborn, meddlesome pensioners as the main characters 😂  If you've read and enjoyed books like The Thursday Murder Club, The Correspondent, The 100-Year-Old Man Who Climbed Out of the Window and Disappeared or A Man Called Ove, you'll definitely love this one!

I also listened to this one on audiobook and, similar to what I said about The Calamity Club, having separate narrators for younger Mabel and present-day Elsie really helped bring the story to life. I very quickly felt really fond of Elsie. She had that stubborn streak that some older folks do, but underneath it all, you know they have a kind heart and mean well. Her dry sense of humour and sarcastic quips made me properly laugh out loud on several occasions!

My favourite thing about this book was the way that, through telling her story, not only is the truth behind Elsie's conviction finally revealed on her own terms, but through the process of sharing her story, she also comes to realise that she now has people around her who truly care for her - something she experienced very little of growing up. The moments when we see the impact this realisation has on her are quite emotional.

The connection she made with some of the other characters (little Persephone in particular) was so heartwarming. The story touches on loneliness and the impact that a lack of a true support network can have on a person's life, and also serves as a lovely reminder that someone doesn't have to be a blood relative to feel like family.

Putting yourself in Mabel's shoes and imagining a situation where you don't have that inner circle of people looking out for you for the majority of your life really makes you thankful for the ones you know will always have your back.
All of this, along with a lovely couple of plot twists at the end, made this one a solid 5 stars for me! 

✨️📚 Book 6 📚✨️

Friday 30th Oct
Mad Mabel - Sally Hepworth

Review #5 - You Killed Me First

Sunday 25th Oct
You Killed Me First - John Marrs

📚 Genre: Psychological thriller 

📚 Synopsis: When newcomer Liv and her seemingly flawless family move into the quiet, upmarket, suburban cul-de-sac where Margot and Anna already live, the three women strike up a friendship, or at least the pretence of one.

On the surface, they each have their own story: Margot is a former pop star looking for a quieter life, Anna runs her own jewellery-making business, and Liv has left her banking career in London to pursue her dream of opening a wellness studio.

But as petty jealousies and suspicion start to creep in, cracks begin to appear in their carefully constructed lives, and each discovers that there is far more to the others than meets the eye. 

📚 My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

There's something to be said for a book that reels you in within the first few pages, and this one does just that! As one review hints at on the front cover, the opening is certainly chilling and piques your interest straight away. I imagine this might be a good one on audiobook, but I read the physical book for this one.

I do enjoy a crime/mystery now and again, but I haven't read too many thrillers before. It probably wouldn't be my typical pick, but this was the November read for my book club, so I'm glad to have tried something outside my usual genres!

Often when reading a book like this, I find myself trying to solve the puzzle as I go along, as I imagine most people do. With this one, I had a hunch that turned out to be right, but my goodness, there were so many twists after that I think I got whiplash! It reached what I thought could have been a sensible ending, then went even further. Think Desperate Housewives meets thriller. Honestly, it's a wild ride!

The way the author links details back to where the story starts in the 2000s and brings them through to the present day is so well planned. Each of the three main characters has a complex backstory that I really enjoyed seeing unfold - Margot especially. I'm not sure why, but I found her character the most fun even though she's very flawed and not the kind of friend you'd want in real life, to put it mildly!

I really enjoyed it and read the majority of the book in one sitting because, my goodness, does John Marrs know how to hold your attention and hit you with about five plot twist curveballs at the same time! I hadn't read anything by him before, so I'd definitely pick up another of his books in future, especially since I've seen other people say this one wasn't their favourite.

The only reason I dropped a star is that I found certain chapters genuinely confusing to follow, and it wasn't until I was about halfway through the book that those chapters started to make sense and I needed to flick back a few times. A solid read all round though!

✨️📚 Book 5 📚✨️

Sunday 25th Oct
You Killed Me First - John Marrs

Review #4: The Calamity Club

Saturday 17th Oct
The Calamity Club - Kathryn Stockett

📚 Genre: Historical Fiction

📚 Synopsis: For this one it was back to 1930s America, this time to Mississippi in the time of the Great Depression. Birdie Calhoun, an outspoken, unmarried woman (heaven forbid), travels from her hometown in the Delta to Oxford to visit her social-climbing sister (who has married rich) in the hope that she can find a way to help her struggling family back home. There, she crosses paths with a quick-witted young orphan called Meg, and Charlie - a fiery, determined woman with a complicated past.

Alongside the latter, Birdie finds herself involved in a daring plan to take back some power for themselves in a town that is determined to keep its citizens, and women in particular, in their place. As the women get to know each other, they begin to challenge the expectations placed on them and find ways to fight back against a society that gives them very little say in their own lives. It's a story about friendship, standing up for what you believe in, and what can happen when you decide not to accept the status quo and take the reins back on your own life.

📚 My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ and a 1/2
Another cracker! I had seen this mentioned a few times on book review accounts on Instagram recently so was keen to give it a try.

If you love a story with strong, witty female leads and a bit of risk taking, this will be up your street. However be warned, it is VERY long (656 pages to be exact!) so it is a bit of a time commitment and that does seem to be a sticking point for some people in other reviews I've seen, but I had plenty of this on our recent long-haul flight so I decided to commit.

I would definitely recommend listening on audiobook if you can though, which is what I did. The narrators voiced the different characters brillliantly and had quite the talent for accents! They brought the dual narration of Birdie and Meg to life so well and did a great job playing to the humour in the dialogue too.

It was full of fun, quirky characters, some really irritating ones (looking at you Frances) and an unusual storyline that had me giggling aloud in places, but also grimacing at some pretty grim parts that were unfortunately a reality of that era. There were parts of the story where I was genuinely quite anxious for Birdie and Charlie, hoping their plans wouldn't get foiled before they had achieved what they wanted to! Birdie and Meg were two definite favourites of mine and whenever I stopped listening for a while I found my thoughts drifting back to them, wondering what would happen next.

My only criticism is that the ending felt a little too abrupt. I wanted just a little bit more detail about what happened next; an epilogue maybe, just to say where each of the key characters were now, because it was such a long book anyway so what's another chapter or so to wrap up all the loose ends?!

I have a bit more detail on the historical reality behind this book because it sat so heavily with me afterwards, so if you're interested, read on...

I'm very conscious that's a few historical fiction books I've done as part of the challenge now, purely because I love that genre but the rest of my list for the challenge are other genres - promise! I do love historical fiction though because I've been introduced to topics that I otherwise didn't really know that much about and have then gone on to read up on a bit more.

This is one example of this, in that the issue at the heart of the story is quite a dark part of US history I wasn't aware of: the sterilisation laws passed in various states during the early 20th century. These laws were essentially rooted in eugenics and the belief that society could be improved by controlling who was allowed to have children. People who were considered to have the "wrong" traits, behaviours or morals could be targeted, including those with disabilities or mental health conditions, those displaying promiscuity, and generally people that were deemed socially undesirable. And, as you can probably imagine, women were disproportionately affected.

The law relevant to this book was passed in Mississippi in 1928. It allowed people living in state institutions to be sterilised if they were considered to fall into certain categories, including "feeble-minded", "insane", "idiotic" or "imbecilic". There was a process for reviewing these decisions, but sterilisation could still happen without the person's consent. In total, 683 people were sterilised under Mississippi's eugenics programme, 523 of them women.

One of the key figures behind the movement in Mississippi was Theodore Bilbo, who became governor in 1928 and strongly supported these ideas. He even advocated setting up a separate institution, or "colony", for people considered "feeble-minded", where they could be kept apart from the rest of society and sterilised. The idea was presented as a way to protect society, but in reality it meant taking away people's most basic rights based on someone else's judgement of their worth.

As I understand it, similar ideas were being pushed in the UK at the time, but attempts to introduce sterilisation legislation never made it into law. It's pretty wild to think how widespread these beliefs were, and how something presented as science could be used to justify treating people in such a horrific way.

So in summary, definitely a heavy topic, but one handled well through careful storytelling. 

✨️📚 Book 4📚✨️

Saturday 17th Oct
The Calamity Club - Kathryn Stockett

Review #3: Normal People

Thursday 15th Oct
Normal People - Sally Rooney

📚 Genre: Contemporary Fiction 

📚 Synopsis: Set in Ireland in the early 2010s, the story follows Marianne and Connell, two teenagers from very different backgrounds who attend the same secondary school. Connell is popular and well-liked among the kids at school, while Marianne is a bit of an outsider who keeps herself to herself.

Despite their differences, they develop a close connection, but their relationship is complicated by their own insecurities and the perceived social hierarchy at school and in life, so at first they try to conceal it.

As they move on and both attend university in Dublin, their lives continue to intertwine, with their relationship shifting back and forth between friendship and romance as they struggle to understand themselves and each other.

In my view it's a story about love, growing up and all the teenage drama that comes with it, and the lasting impact that certain people can have on our lives.

📚 My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️
This was an interesting one. I've never read anything by Sally Rooney before and I'm not sure if this is her style in her other books, but the way she wrote dialogue between characters is very to the point, no speech marks etc. (Google tells me this is called Spare Prose) and there is often a jump back to recalling a previous memory as well, so both of those techniques make it seem almost like you're there inside their thoughts. So her writing itself I liked and found really engaging and I finished the book really quickly as a result, but where it drops stars for me is on the storyline itself.

Although there are themes that are relatable like the insecurities of growing up through teenage years and grappling with the social expectations from their peers and what that means for their relationship, I found the storyline quite repetitive and the main characters quite frustrating to be honest. And maybe that's the point,  because a lot of their problems seemed to stem from a lack of ability to communicate properly with each other about how they felt, but as someone who does nothing but share how I'm feeling I just got a bit exasperated at the characters, almost shouting through the pages at them, 'Why did you say that?!' or 'Just tell her for goodness sake!' 😂

Neither of them were characters that left much of an impression or made me feel anything for them, and both were a bit self obsessed in their own ways. It also didn't have a very satisfying ending, and neither of the characters seemed to have changed much in the course of the book in that they were still making the same mistakes they did as teenagers, so it all just felt a bit flat as I closed the book over. 

But again, it might just be me because the front cover mentions an award win so who knows, you might read it and love it! 

✨️📚 Book 3 📚✨️

Thursday 15th Oct
Normal People - Sally Rooney

Review #2: The Giver of Stars

Tuesday 13th Oct
The Giver of Stars - Jojo Moyes

📚 Genre: Historical Fiction/Romance

📚 Synopsis: Set in 1930s Kentucky, the story follows Alice Wright, who is swept up in a whirlwind romance with handsome American Bennett Van Cleve while he is travelling through England. They swiftly marry, and Alice moves across the world to rural Kentucky, where Bennett works alongside his father, the owner of a local mining company. However, she soon realises she's left behind one oppressive household, that of her parents, only to find herself in another.

When the opportunity comes up to volunteer for the local Pack Horse Library Project, Alice jumps at the chance to get involved. Delivering books on horseback to isolated mountain communities alongside the other librarians, she finds a sense of purpose and adventure that her new married life has been missing. But as the women develop close friendships, their bond and determination are put to the test when one of them faces real hardship...

📚 My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I loved this one! It had actually been recommended to me a while back, but I'd just never got round to reading it. I was reminded of it again recently when a history account I follow on Instagram posted a few photos of women working for a Pack Horse Library in Kentucky in the 1930s. This was part of a New Deal initiative run by the Works Progress Administration (WPA), which aimed to improve access to books and literacy in rural communities and was championed by Eleanor Roosevelt. These amazing women rode horses and mules to deliver books and magazines to people living in remote areas, which immediately caught my interest as I'd never heard of the project before. When I spotted someone in the comments mentioning that The Giver of Stars was about this, I knew I had to give it a read!

I was hooked from the first page. The writing is so engaging and descriptive that I really felt as though I was up in the foothills of the Kentucky mountains, delivering books alongside them! The characters have so much depth that you become really invested in their individual stories, and the bond that develops between these very different women through their shared purpose and love of books is just wonderful to read.

It also touches on issues of classism, racism and sexism of the time, but at its heart it's a beautiful story of female friendship and community, and the power that a bond like that can have when one of the group faces real hardship and their sisterhood is put to the test.

Needless to say, I cried several times reading this one! Although I suspect I cry more than your average person at books 😂, I always think it's a sign that you've really connected with the characters and their stories, and that was definitely the case here.

Margery was a particular favourite. In my mind, she was a bit like Calamity Jane from the musical of the same name - headstrong, independent, a follower of her own rules and not one to conform to the typical expectations of how a woman of that time should look or behave. She was completely unapologetic about it too, which I loved!

Fantastic read! I'd definitely recommend this one, particularly if you're a fellow historical fiction fan, but also if you just love a good story you can lose yourself in. 

📚✨️Book 2✨️📚

Tuesday 13th Oct
The Giver of Stars - Jojo Moyes

Review #1: The Things We Leave Unfinished - Rebecca Yarros

Wednesday 23rd Sep
📚 Book: The Things We Leave Unfinished - Rebecca Yarros

📚 Genre: Historical Fiction/Romance

📚 Synopsis: Set on a dual timeline between current day Colorado and World War II England, the story follows Georgia Stanton, granddaughter of acclaimed romance author Scarlett Stanton. After her grandmother's death (not a spoiler 😂), Georgia sets out to publish the one story her grandmother never managed to finish - a manuscript that until now existed only as pages typed on her typewriter, documenting her life during the war and how she came to meet the love of her life. She enlists the help of bestselling romance author, Noah Harrison, to finish the story, and as the manuscript comes to life, it becomes clear that there was much more to Scarlett's story than Georgia ever knew.

📚 My rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️( and a 1/2)
While I really liked the storyline of this one and loved the plot twist near the end, it just fell a little short of what I think it could have been. For me, the flashbacks to Scarlett and Jameson's story during the war weren't quite as realistically captured as other books I've read based during that period (Kristin Hannah's The Nightingale springs to mind), and the way the characters spoke was too similar to that of conversations between Georgia and Noah in the chapters that were based in the current day. In theory the story should have had me crying my eyes out at parts (I cry at everything!) but I really struggled to feel the emotions the characters would have been feeling and unfortunately I think that was down to the author's writing style and choice of words. Overall it's a decent read and has a 4 star rating on Goodreads so maybe it's just me, but it just left me feeling disappointed that I didn't like it more! On to the next...

📚✨️ Book 1 ✨️📚

Sunday 20th Sep
The Things We Leave Unfinished - Rebecca Yarros

Book 1 of the Winter Reading Challenge

Sunday 20th Sep
Hi all 👋

This winter, I’m taking part in Dementia UK’s Winter Reading Challenge, which I just had to get involved in as it’s a cause that’s very close to my family’s heart ❤️

I already had a goal to get out of my reading rut this year, and now I’ve set myself the challenge of reading 11 more books before the end of the year, taking my total to 26 books for 2026, while raising money to support people living with dementia and their families 📚

Anything you can spare for this important cause would be hugely appreciated, and I’ll share progress updates and my thoughts on the books I read along the way, just in case anyone is looking for some reading recommendations! 

Book number 1 of the challenge is The Things We Leave Unfinished by Rebecca Yarros 📖✨️

Thank you to my Sponsors

£50

Andreea Virban-aldev

Amazing goal, Imi! Cannot wait for the recommendations! Lots of love, Andreea, Zelda, Scottie and Stefan

£30

Granny Morag &. Grandad Woodie X

Good Luck Imogen you’ll smash it as you’ve always loved reading and you do things with all your heart Well Done wonderful charity ❤️ 👏👏

£20

Innes Cuthill

£20

Liz Rankin

You will smash this ❤️x

£20

Joanna

£20

Auntie Gail, Uncle Gary, Josh & Tilly

You have always loved a book. Proud of you. Lots of Love xx

£20

Jeni Robbie

£20

Kirkwood Family

Hope you are getting some good book recommendations. 😉 xx

£20

Imogen Macdonald

£15

Georgia Ogilvie

Well done Imogen - love reading your reviews! Your gran will be so proud of you! ❤️

£10

Margaret Mcleman

Great cause, good luck Imogen x

£10

Catriona

Well done Imogen 💕

£10

Craig Wilson

Enjoy all the lovely books!

£10

Beth Harper

What a lovely thing to do, and for the perfect cause. I will be following for book recommendations too! 🥰

£10

Fiona Watson

Great idea and a very worthy cause. Good luck, I’m sure you’ll nail it xx

£10

Emma Brand

£5

Louise Ballantyne

Great charity! Well done Imogen :-)

£5

Michaella